Is AI making your law firm less visible?

Media item displaying Is AI making your law firm less visible?

The legal sector is stepping further into a hall of mirrors, where mass-produced AI content is making specialist expertise harder to distinguish.

Rewriting a law firm’s website has traditionally been a considerable undertaking, often involving hundreds of pages covering practices, industries and experience. AI has transformed that process.

ChatGPT, Claude and other platforms can generate legal marketing content at unprecedented volume and speed. They can adjust your firm’s tone and structure your key pages, weaving in keywords and suggesting alternatives in a matter of seconds. Right Hat leverages these same tools every day: the value here is considerable for busy legal marketing teams.

This value, however, is met with equal risks. We’re seeing first-hand how new vulnerabilities are emerging with overreliance on AI,  many of which aren’t always obvious from the finished copy.

Hallucinations and The Great Flattening

For instance, content can be wildly inaccurate or insufficiently supported, with even the most advanced tools still prone to hallucination. The latest models continue to produce incorrect citations and fabricated case law. These errors expose the growing gap between the convenience of generative AI and the evidentiary demands underpinning the legal sector. 

Across the legal digital landscape, many websites sound plausible. However, few reflect the details that distinguish one attorney’s experience from another. Content can be accurate in the broadest sense, but rarely tells the story of the regulatory environments they’ve navigated, the kind of clients they’ve routinely advised or the perspectives they’ve honed from doing this kind of work. 

Here at Right Hat, we refer to this as The Great Flattening: the gradual loss of meaningful distinction as highly specific expertise is translated into increasingly similar language.

This Great Flattening comes at a time when legal buyers are telling us they want the kind of information that generative AI tools tend to miss. Our 2026 Top of Mind Survey found that when evaluating law firm service descriptions, 82% of legal buyers want information about industry experience. Meanwhile, 82% want clearly defined areas of focus and 75% want information about recent matters. 

Our concern is that the mass production of generic content without experienced editorial input is making this specificity harder to find. This, of course, presents opportunities for organizations that act now.

Your firm’s discoverability is changing

These opportunities are becoming more significant as AI transforms how legal buyers discover information. Our proprietary research found that 70% of legal services buyers use AI-powered tools instead of or alongside law firm content for their research. Your website may no longer be their first encounter with your organization. Increasingly, that may happen through an AI-generated answer drawn from information found elsewhere.

Your content now has two audiences: the people evaluating your firm and the AI platforms trying to understand what your firm knows.

AEO (Answer Engine Optimization) and GEO (Generative Engine Optimization) have emerged as important practices for improving how that expertise is understood, surfaced and cited by AI-powered search. Both depend on clear, specific information that buyers and AI platforms can interpret.

Review, restructure, rewrite: Is more content the solution?

Like many of our clients, you may be asking yourself how you can respond to this new reality with more content. To that, we present a more useful question: is your firm’s existing content performing well enough in reflecting the expertise behind it?

We encourage firms to think about some of the most important content their sites already host: practice descriptions, attorney bios, industry pages. These are often the places to begin identifying AEO and GEO opportunities through a focused editorial review. This can involve:

  • Reviewing existing content to pinpoint outdated information, generic claims or areas where your specialist expertise is poorly reflected or not reflected at all.
  • Restructuring important pages to give greater prominence to relevant experience, specialist areas of focus and supporting evidence, making that information more likely for AI platforms – and buyers – to find and understand.
  • Rewriting ‘generic’ content to communicate what truly distinguishes your attorneys, their unique experience and the specific types of clients they advise.
  • Enhancing your existing content with representative matters, relevant industry insights and answers to questions asked by potential clients.

These improvements can help existing content communicate more about your firm without necessarily increasing the volume of material on your website. Again and again, we’re seeing the value in website projects where information and expertise are being taken directly from the people who possess it. Experienced writers are the catalyst behind these success stories.

Unlike an LLM, these professionals can interview a partner and identify what’s worth saying. They can extract meaningful insights from an incidental comment. They can flag claims that demand evidence and recognize when legal precision gets in the way of useful communication.

It’s a question of judgment, just as it always has been.

Putting AI to work

None of this is an argument against AI. It has transformed the work we do as legal marketers, largely for the better. AI allows us to analyze large volumes of content, examine competitor positioning and identify gaps and opportunities with greater efficiency. It has also accelerated the research and editorial processes that underpin our work.

The opportunity is in putting these capabilities to work without outsourcing the judgment that gives them value. That’s the driving principle behind Right Hat’s approach to website content.

We combine the analytical capabilities of AI with experienced legal editors who translate your complex expertise into something useful for people and the machines answering their questions. This work is based on a foundation of credible evidence, established through a data-informed baseline. We do this by:

  • Examining how your current content is performing against selected competitors.
  • Interrogating how effectively your distinctive areas of expertise are represented.
  • Identifying the potential gulf between what your attorneys know and what your site communicates.
  • Analyzing how your firm is surfaced and cited across AI-generated results.

This baseline helps us identify where your firm’s expertise could be better represented and made more discoverable. We act on those opportunities by partnering with your firm, conducting interviews with attorneys and facilitating workshops to understand their practices and industries. We combine this with Right Hat’s proprietary research into what legal buyers actually want from your firm’s website. We use this to create content that makes your expertise easier to understand, evaluate and discover.

The results of our work are measurable. We revisit your baseline after the updated content has had time to take effect, establishing where your firm has gained ground and where further opportunities remain.

Any agency promising immediate, guaranteed AI visibility should be treated with healthy skepticism. The fields of AEO and GEO are still emerging, and our understanding of how artificial intelligence generates answers continues to evolve. What we can do for your firm now is improve the quality, specificity and accessibility of the evidence those platforms have to work with.

If you’re wondering how well your current website is making the case for your firm, we’d be happy to help. Our benchmark testing is available now at no cost and with no obligation. Contact Jeorjina Tegel today to discover how your firm is performing against competitors in the AI landscape. 

A human will take everything else from there.